× Home About Jessica Our Listings Home Search Sold Listings Home Valuation Neighborhoods Testimonials Buyer's Guide Seller's Guide Mortgage Calculator Let's Connect
For Sale

452-454 Fifth, Black River-Matheson, Ontario P0K 1N0

$729,000
4 Bedrooms
5 Bathrooms
NaN sq ft
1 Garage

About This Property

A versatile triple-lot property featuring a church, spacious community event centre, detached garage and a 4-bedroom residence. With multiple spaces, abundant storage, and valuable updates throughout, this property offers tremendous potential for a variety of uses. The church building is 4980 sqft above ground features a welcoming sanctuary with office space, and a 2-piece bathroom on the main level. The church's 4500 sqft lower level contains three forced-air furnaces. Attached to the church is the Community Events Centre, offering a large auditorium with a stage, making it ideal for gatherings, performances, meetings and community events. The Centre's lower level includes a spacious hall with a kitchen and bathrooms. The 1325 sqft home provides a comfortable living space and excellent functionality. The second level features four bedrooms and a 4-piece bathroom. On the main level, you'll find a spacious living room, separate dining room, and kitchen complete with fridge and stove. A generous office with built-in cupboards and additional storage makes an ideal workspace or flex room. Additional highlights include a detached 24' x 12' garage and approximately four parking spaces. Notable updates include the metal roofs on both the church and house (2019), church windows (2009), and Community Events Centre doors (2020), along with one of the church's gas forced-air furnaces replaced in 2024. *Taxes will be reassessed for a new buyer. **Age: Church is approximately 117 years old with 2 additions and House is approximately 80 years old.

Home Details

CategoryResidentialProperty
StyleOther
TypeSale
StatusA
Days on Market–
List DateAug 17, 2026
Last Updated OnOct 23, 2026
Year Built100+

Features

Total Beds4
Baths5
Heating TypeForced Air
Air ConditioningNone
FireplacesNo
Total Parking1
BasementOther
MLS NumberT13689166

Exterior

ConstructionBuilt in 100+
Construction DetailsStandard Frame
Roof MaterialFlat, Metal, Other
ExteriorHardboard Siding

Water & Sewer

Water SupplyMunicipal
SewerSewers

Legal

Brokerage–
Jessica

Jessica Thyriar

Real Estate Agent
+1 (416) 732-6397